Monday, May 13, 2013

Butterscotch Chewy Cake - Vintage Pillsbury Award Winner!

"Nostalgia is a file that removes the rough edges from the good old days." 
- Doug Larson

I was shopping at our local thrift store and I heard the employees talking. I heard the words, "wow this is old! What is it? Is it a scrap book? It's recipes! This is so cool!" I promptly came over and said, "O.K. what are you talking about, and where is it?"

What they were referring to was this book I'll call The Scrapbook. It was made from a tailors book that talks about their prices and the clothes they offer. Nowadays it would be a brochure, but this is a full on hard cover book. The owner of this book glued recipes over the pages. There are a few calenders glued to the back page, the first one starts in 1926. Google tells me this recipe from a Pillsbury baking contest dates to 1955. At least thirty years of recipes have been collected in this book, her whole adult life.

This recipe is easy to make. You just need a bowl, a whisk and a spoon.

I'm a lover of vintage items. I have my own vintage shop, even. So I was all over this. This book tells a story about the times through food. I started to think about it. My father is 80 years old. He was born in 1933. He was a child during the later years of the making of this book. This book was made by someone who lived during his mothers era.

Right before going in the oven

It was the depression. There was no internet. How did they get recipes? Probably through friends, people at church and passed down from their mothers. Cookbooks, if you could afford them.

Right out of the oven

Newspaper articles and food labels with delicious sounding recipes must have felt like a gift. What a perfectly sensible idea to glue them to the pages of an already existing book! During a depression you do what you gotta do to provide your family with a tasty and hearty meal. A great and timeless lesson in resourcefulness.

The scrapbook made from a tailors book, I love how art deco it is.

I have a collection of vintage cookbooks myself, but this was more special. More personal. I wanted to cook from it right away.

This is incredible. She used it her whole adult life, 30 years of collecting. There are calenders glued to the back from 1926, and the recipe I used from a label that dates to 1955. 

Loose in the last few pages of the book was a leaflet from Pillsbury, with the recipes of the prize winners from 1955. Turns out Pillsbury has been sponsoring baking contests for 64 years and counting.

The book includes recipes of all kinds

The recipe that caught my eye was this butterscotch chewy cake. I love the flavor of butterscotch and it was easy and quite straightforward. I crossed my fingers that the recipe would still work after all of these years.

There are pictures! It is interesting to me to see what was in fashion.

I'm happy to announce that yes, indeed it did work. It produced exactly what it advertises. A chewy cake. The texture is a cross between a snack cake and a blondie, or a brownie. I enjoyed it alone as a casual snack in the afternoon. But we really devoured it topped with butter pecan ice cream and caramel sauce. A sundae is how this cake shines. The texture stands up to the ice cream and caramel without getting soggy. And since the weather around here has been unseasonably warm, it was a welcome treat.

Even handwritten recipes, waffle cake, sounds good!

The cake is super easy to make. It really just takes a few minutes to throw together. It's just a few basic ingredients, eggs, flour, lots of pecans, etc. - with one exception. Scotch. Scotch whiskey to be specific.

There are even diet tips.

Scotch isn't included in the original recipe, I added it. Here's why. I've made a few different butterscotch desserts in my life, (I'm not talking about artificially flavored butterscotch like those chips) that included it. It really brings home the taste of butterscotch without tasting like alcohol, since it's baked. If you absolutely can't use alcohol you can go ahead and omit it. But I do recommend it for the best flavor.

labels with recipes

While I'm very happy about my new book, I'm also a little sad, that this book isn't in the hands of the family of it's creator. More and more in this digital age I find people don't hold onto things like they used to. I attend garage sales where they are selling their mothers items and not passing them down like previous generations would. With shows on TV like Hoarders, no one wants to be a pack rat. Which part of me totally understands.

Call me sentimental, but I like these little pieces of yesteryear, in a tangible form to hold in my hands and dream about times past.

My free range chickens are always looking for a treat. I think they thought I was bringing this outside for them.
Never miss a post! Follow The Alchemist on Facebook! Or Pinterest

 Vintage Etched Drinking Glasses, Antique Johnson Bros Plates, English Ironstone Pitcher with Pink Roses, Towle Sterling Silver Spoon, and Baby Pink Cloth Napkins available at my Etsy shop, House of Lucien.

Enter coupon code ALCHEMY at House of Lucien for 20 percent off of your order! 

Butterscotch Chewy Cake

Adapted from the 2nd prize winner of Pillsbury Grand National Recipe and Baking Contest 1955, Mrs. Richard Enloe Atlanta, Georgia


4 eggs

2 tsp vanilla

2 cups (400 g.) packed brown sugar

2 Tablespoons butter - melted

1 1/2 cups (190 g.) sifted all purpose flour - sift first then measure

1 1/2 tsp baking powder

1/2 tsp salt

1 1/2 cups (146 g.) chopped pecans

3 Tablespoons Scotch Whiskey (optional, but recommended)

For serving

Ice cream, butter pecan or vanilla or whipped cream - optional

Store bought or homemade Caramel Sauce - optional


Preheat the oven to 350 degrees Fahrenheit, 180 degrees Celsius, Gas Mark 4. Grease well a 13 x 9 inch pan, set aside.

Beat the eggs in a large bowl. Add brown sugar, vanilla and melted butter and stir together. In another medium bowl, whisk together the flour, baking powder and salt. Add to the egg mixture and stir together well, until incorporated. Add the chopped nuts and the scotch whiskey (if using) and stir again until well blended.

Pour batter into prepared pan. Bake for 25 minutes or until it springs back lightly when touched lightly in the center, and until a toothpick inserted in the center comes out clean.

Serve with whipped cream or ice cream, I used butter pecan ice cream and store bought caramel sauce for topping and it was marvelous!


Liz said...

This looks so delicious! Love the pics of your chickens running around your photo shoot!

Mindy said...

How fun! And it sounds yummy, too.
I love the chickens as well. I'm a wee bit jealous that you have them runnin' around the yard. :)

With A Blast said...

Loved the post and pinned the recipe!

With A Blast

Anonymous said...

That is pretty neat!! It also shows how valuable paper was back then. We have so much paper today, we really don't understand how people used and reused it prior to the 1950s. In the 1800s, every bit of paper was precious; Emily Dickinson sometimes wrote her poems or notes to friends on the back of recipes or lists.
As for the book... that is pretty nifty. Maybe more so for me because my family still does it! Not with recycled paper, but to pass recipes along. I'm about to do it for a friend's birthday next month. :) Passing recipes is lovely when you scrapbook it for someone else! Even better if you leave pages blank or use a binder so more recipes can be added. About half-way through my childhood, my mom started getting lazy and kept her clippings in a rolodex, though. Still trying to get her to scrapbook them, haha.

The Alchemist said...

violent-koe - That's a good point, about paper being valuable, I didn't even think of that.

And you're so right, scrapbooking recipes is a wonderful gift. Something I think would be fun to do also. Thanks so much for the idea, and for your interesting input!

Blissful & Domestic said...

I love this! Old recipes and cookbooks are a passion of mine. What a neat find!

Christine said...

I sooo NEED to try that recipe! YUM!!

Thanks so much for sharing this at The DIY Dreamer... From Dream To Reality! I can't wait to see what you link up tomorrow evening!

Blissful & Domestic said...

Hi Lady! I featured you today on Blissful and Domestic. Stop by and check it out:>

Danielle @ Blissful & Domestic

Anonymous said...

I love love love this! Just think of it as she was the last in her line and that you were the lucky (and most appropriate) home for her labor of love.

99Silverlady said...

I am very lucky to have the Pillsbury 1955 cookbook that this recipe came out of. Cost was $.25 back then. I also have recipes that date back before the Civil War, but for me to find this complete cookbook from 1955 is a real treasure!

Unknown said...

Grandbaby Cakes offers delicious pillsbury recipes for everyone. The flavor is undeniable, and the best part is the entire thing can be made in one pot.

smokegood said...

When you first join the world of online casinos, it can be a little confusing at times. Payout percentages are something that we get lots of questions about.
Put simply, payout percentages represent the amount of money a casino pays out relative to the amount that a player spends.
The payout percentage, sometimes called RTP (Return to Player), is an averaged figure.
This means that it's best to treat the number as a guide, as you could easily receive less than or more than this amount when you play.
Either way, it's fair to assume that the higher the percentage, the better the online casino, but you can't discount the other elements that help make the best payout casinos what they are.

Unknown said...

Thank you so much for posting this recipe. We had this recipe when I was growing up. And somehow I managed to lose my copy AND my mother's copy. I have tried other "butterscotch brownie" recipes, but they are never as good as this one. I just might have to print this out and frame it! :)

jrichard said...

Pauline (Mrs. Richard) Enloe was my maternal grandmother. Chewycake was a family recipe she entered in the 1954 Pillsbury Bake-Off, winning 2nd Prize.
Your spin on her recipe looks very good. But I cannot bring myself to the addition of Scotch to this old-fashioned treat.
I will however thank you for raising my grandmother's name.
Have a lovely.